FNMA's New Income Calculator ft. Jim Carroll

Hi there and welcome to another episode of The MikedUp Show! Recently, we had a conversation that sits right at the intersection of underwriting, technology, and the future of mortgage operations. With Jim Carroll, Head of Home Lending at Partners Bank, we explored what may be one of the most meaningful shifts in agency lending in years: Fannie Mae’s Income Analyzer.

While underwriting has always been a cornerstone of risk management, the way income is calculated (and more importantly, who calculates it) is undergoing a fundamental transformation. What we uncovered in this discussion is not just a new tool, but a shift in accountability, efficiency, and how lenders can think about scaling their businesses

Truework is the only all-in-one, automated VOIE platform that fully replaces costly in-house verification waterfalls by orchestrating all major verification methods within a single platform. With an industry-leading 75% completion rate, we have helped mortgage providers achieve up to 50% cost savings on their verification process, resulting in multi-million dollar savings. Looking to save on verification costs while improving borrower experience and pull-through? Let’s talk.

FROM INTERPRETATION TO AUTOMATION

Underwriting has always relied on human interpretation. Even with the introduction of automated underwriting systems like Desktop Underwriter, the responsibility for calculating income remained in the hands of lenders. The system could approve or deny a file, but only based on the numbers entered by a human. Jim highlighted how this paradigm is changing. “They were approving the file… but it was still approving what income you entered into the file and you calculated,” he explained.

Fannie’s new Income Calculator flips that model on its head. Instead of lenders calculating income and hoping it aligns with agency expectations, the system itself now performs the calculation using the borrower’s tax returns. That distinction may seem minor, but its implications are significant. In one example Jim shared, a borrower with slightly declining income would traditionally have been evaluated using the most recent year, potentially pushing their debt-to-income ratio above approval thresholds. However, the Income Analyzer evaluated the full picture and determined the income to be stable, allowing the use of a two-year average. What this represents is a shift away from rigid guideline interpretation toward a more holistic, data-driven analysis performed by the agency itself.

FundingShield is the market leader in embedded wire and title fraud prevention, closing agent vetting, and compliance automation. With over $4.5 trillion in mortgage and real estate transactions protected, our solutions deliver unmatched security and efficiency. Lenders rely on our real-time, source-verified, decision-ready data to safeguard funds, streamline workflows, and reduce operating costs across closing and title workflows. Contact sales@fundingshield.com to discover how we can help you close with confidence.

REPS & WARRANTS REIMAGINED WITH REDUCED RISK

Perhaps the most consequential impact of this technology lies in its effect on reps and warrants. For lenders, few risks are more significant than a loan buyback, particularly when it stems from income miscalculation. Historically, that risk has been tied directly to human error. A miscalculation, a missed adjustment, or even a simple data entry mistake could result in a file that fails post-close review. Jim described this risk in straightforward terms. “When you lose the reps and warrants… you’re at a loss. You can’t fight back on that.”

By shifting income calculation to Fannie Mae itself, lenders gain a level of protection that was previously difficult to achieve. If the agency calculates and approves the income, it becomes significantly harder for that same agency to later challenge the decision. This doesn’t eliminate risk entirely, but it changes the nature of it. Instead of defending internal calculations, lenders can rely on agency-generated findings tied directly to the loan file. In an environment where repurchase demands remain a persistent concern, that shift alone has the potential to reshape how lenders approach underwriting going forward.

SPEED, ACCURACY, & SCALE - THE INCOME CALCULATOR’S IMPACT

Beyond risk mitigation, the operational efficiencies introduced by Fannie’s Income Calculator are equally compelling. Traditional income calculation - particularly for self-employed borrowers - can be time-consuming and prone to inconsistency. Jim noted that manual calculation could take several minutes per file, with the added risk of “fat fingering” data during entry. By integrating with platforms like Friday Harbor, the process becomes nearly instantaneous. That reduction in time is not just about convenience. It has direct implications for scale. When income calculation becomes a near-instant process, underwriters can move through files more efficiently, lenders can process higher volumes, and operational bottlenecks begin to ease. As Jim put it, “It’s about being able to produce more units with less cost.” In that context, Income Analyzer is not just a tool: it’s an enabler of scale.

SHIFT KNOWLEDGE UPSTREAM & EMPOWER YOUR ORIGINATORS

One of the more impactful shifts discussed in the episode was how this technology changes the role of the loan originator. Traditionally, income calculation has been something that happens deeper in the process, often leaving LOs reliant on processors or underwriters to validate assumptions. The Income Calculator changes that dynamic. With the tool accessible at the front end of the process, originators can now validate income scenarios before submitting a file. This reduces surprises, shortens cycle times, and improves the borrower experience. “Fannie Mae’s already calculated the income. There’s no argument,” Jim explained. That level of certainty opens the door to serving more complex borrower profiles, including self-employed individuals and those with variable income streams. This shift represents an opportunity to rethink how lenders train and empower their teams. When originators have access to the same tools and insights as underwriters, the entire process becomes more aligned and efficient

Full episode

To hear more lively discussions and special guest insights in the realm of mortgages and real estate, check out TheMikedUp Show with Mike Kelleher and Michael Zau, every Thursday at 2pmET!

THE ABOVE IS A SUMMARY OF INSIGHTS & ANECDOTES TAKEN FROM AN HOUR-LONG PODCAST EPISODE OF THEMIKEDUP SHOW. MIKE & MIKE RESERVE THE RIGHT TO PARAPHRASE WHEREVER NECESSARY.